It is general public knowledge that Christina Aguilera is one of my favorite pop stars, and probably people in general. My beloved Xtina can do no wrong in my eyes. Sadly, lately it has become very tiring to be this adoring and defensive of her; Christina’s exploits in the past year or so have not done much to frame her in a positive light. I have tried to stay supportive, then this morning I wake up to the horrific news that she and her boyfriend have been arrested (or, “detained” ?) for alcohol-related charges! Xtina, NO!! The world is turning against her and it’s become increasingly more difficult to lend her my undying affection. Look at what I already have to deal with:
me: I’m so sad for her :(
Caroline: she is turning into Lindsay
me: NO she is not. She just had one slip-up
Caroline: thats all it takes!
Caroline: she is still a drunken mess!
me: AREN’T WE ALL, THOUGH?
I have put Christina Aguilera on a pedestal for so long. Now I am starting to question my entire belief system. The only way to put my thoughts and emotions into perspective is to conduct a point-counterpoint regarding modern-day Christina, comparing my life to hers and seeing who is really coming out on top.
Point: Christina is so beautiful! She has such a killer body and old-school glamour! I am just a regular person!
Counterpoint: Lately the web has been ablaze with criticism of her weight gain and sometimes over-the-top makeup. Granted, we all have our moments, and Christina is now a mother and getting into her 30s, so we can’t have unrealistic expectations here. Regrettably, it must be said that her body these days is considerably less bangin’ even than when she was doing Burlesque last year. Even so, she is very gorgeous. I am still just a regular person, but at least I have not gained any weight and no one makes fun of my lipstick, because I do not wear lipstick. Plus, did Xtina have a boob job?! I don’t know. But I didn’t.
CA vs ET: …nobody comes out on top in this battle. We are both just women doing the best we can.
Point: Christina has an amazing singing voice! She was invited to sing the national anthem at the Superbowl, do an Aretha Franklin tribute at the Grammys, has starred in countless music videos and gone on concert tours, including one with Justin Timberlake! All I get to do is karaoke… sometimes sing in the shower… sometimes blast the Comcast “Music Choice Hot Hits” station while I clean the house… and that’s about as close as I’ll ever get to musical superstardom.
Counterpoint: Yeah, but if I am singing karaoke and make a dumb mistake with the lyrics, no one cares or probably even notices. Christina messed up the lyrics to the national anthem and American reamed her for it. Then she did the Grammys and bizarrely fell down during the end of the tribute, and had to be helped up by Jennifer Hudson or someone. Embarrassing! At least all the stupid crap that happens at the Rickshaw when I “perform” my musical “talents” will never be in the public eye and is easily forgotten two seconds after it occurs.
CA vs ET: Once again, equal. Being famous is still awesome. But so is having your humiliations NOT immortalized and commented on by strangers on the internet who think they are entitled to have an opinion about you.
Point: Christina married for ~love~ and not looks/money and has the most adorable little son, Max! All my relationships (haha, “all”) are confusing and do not ever result in me getting a bridal spread in OK! magazine!
Counterpoint: Buuuuut then she and J.Bratman (who, let’s be honest, not exactly a stunner in the looks department) filed for divorce last year. And now she is a single mom who is already dating someone new, a dude who also seems to be a bit beneath her and also has a penchant for alcohol abuse. Hmmm Christina, is someone not valuing herself enough? I am not divorced. I also did not have a a hit single “Ain’t No Other Man” publicly praising the man I ended up divorcing.
CA vs ET: Emily wins?!
Point: Christina Aguilera has never been in a stupid celebrity DUI scandal. Of course, neither have I. Actually, come to think of it, I don’t think either of us have been in trouble with the po whatsoever.
Counterpoint: Oh yeahhh except for this morning… this happened. I can’t claim I have never shamed while drinking, but nothing to this degree whatsoever.
CA vs ET: Shockingly, Emily clearly comes out on top once more.
So while Christina Aguilera is clearly more famous and absolutely beautiful, is it possible that my life is going a little better than hers at this point?! No police run-ins while wasted, no divorce, no public scrutiny after messing up a high-profile performance… my life may not be all figured out, but at the same time it is not unraveling. I guess this means Christina needs my love and support more than EVER! Maybe I can be a good influence on her. For example, right now at 11am I am drinking a mug of hot water and eating a banana at my desk, in lieu of pounding a bottle of vodka in the car with my trashy rebound bf at 2am? Are you taking notes, Xtina?
On a related note, the DVD of Burlesque came out today. We are watching it tonight in Christina’s honor.